Recent Public Posts - [guest]
| Re: Different outlooks on nationalisation - GWR and Chiltern In "Chiltern Railways services" [381972/32728/44] Posted by TaplowGreen at 04:47, 16th November 2026 | ![]() |
Probably wise from GWR given the rolling stock issues.
Indeed. It feels like the perennial issue problem of the GWR franchise going back 20+ years has been stock availability, which has been almost entirely down to the DfT.
Yes, GWR area rolling stock has been the big privatisation problem. There had been big investments in 1976-1982 with HSTs, some investment on the regional Wessex and South West in late 1980s with the pacers, 155s, 158s etc. Then Network South East introduced the 165 suburban and 166 outer suburban DMUs.
Then it sort of went completely wrong and nothing really happened for 23 years from about 1993 to 2016. At best was really some repainting and patching up.
Then the electrification (later truncated) seem to lead to more of a bodge and hiatus. The IETs, which needed late fuel tank size and engine up-spec, 387s getting moved to Heathrow Express, Elizabeth line taking over local services, displacing trains, Thames Valley branches and Gatwick line staying diesel so needing the trains that should have moved west. A fleet of aging DMUs replacing the pacers. Bristol based regional routes getting stuck with class 165s still in inner suburban configuration
And at the time of nationalisation late 2026, nothing on order. Even though the sleeper fleet is 40+ years old, the class 150s are 39-40 years old, the 158, 165, 166 (and SWR 159s) are 34-37 years old. No apparent forward plan (beyond unfunded ideas).
So as it tends to take 4-7 years to introduce any new trains, what is plan 2026-2032. Basically seems to be unreliable 175s (which are 25 years old), and some ex Wales 158s (already 36 years old), no positivity, just a bodge until 2030s with others hand-me-downs
I think you can be reassured, if it's any consolation, that there is no need to worry about radical change

| Re: Different outlooks on nationalisation - GWR and Chiltern In "Chiltern Railways services" [381971/32728/44] Posted by John D at 04:11, 16th November 2026 | ![]() |
Probably wise from GWR given the rolling stock issues.
Indeed. It feels like the perennial issue problem of the GWR franchise going back 20+ years has been stock availability, which has been almost entirely down to the DfT.
Yes, GWR area rolling stock has been the big privatisation problem. There had been big investments in 1976-1982 with HSTs, some investment on the regional Wessex and South West in late 1980s with the pacers, 155s, 158s etc. Then Network South East introduced the 165 suburban and 166 outer suburban DMUs.
Then it sort of went completely wrong and nothing really happened for 23 years from about 1993 to 2016. At best was really some repainting and patching up.
Then the electrification (later truncated) seem to lead to more of a bodge and hiatus. The IETs, which needed late fuel tank size and engine up-spec, 387s getting moved to Heathrow Express, Elizabeth line taking over local services, displacing trains, Thames Valley branches and Gatwick line staying diesel so needing the trains that should have moved west. A fleet of aging DMUs replacing the pacers. Bristol based regional routes getting stuck with class 165s still in inner suburban configuration
And at the time of nationalisation late 2026, nothing on order. Even though the sleeper fleet is 40+ years old, the class 150s are 39-40 years old, the 158, 165, 166 (and SWR 159s) are 34-37 years old. No apparent forward plan (beyond unfunded ideas).
So as it tends to take 4-7 years to introduce any new trains, what is plan 2026-2032. Basically seems to be unreliable 175s (which are 25 years old), and some ex Wales 158s (already 36 years old), no positivity, just a bodge until 2030s with others hand-me-downs
| Re: Different outlooks on nationalisation - GWR and Chiltern In "Chiltern Railways services" [381970/32728/44] Posted by JayMac at 03:08, 16th November 2026 | ![]() |
Ironic with Chiltern Railways having been one of the big success stories of privatisation!
It's easy to see how Chiltern have faired relatively better than GWT/FGW(Thames Trains/Wessex Trains)/GWR. Those franchise changes alone brought instability to the Greater Western franchise. Chiltern remained largely self contained. Less competition for Chiltern too, be that for passengers, or track access slots. Greater Western's disparate needs brought more complicated management, with differing staff contracts and union agreements. A varied mix of rolling stock has proved difficult to maintain too. What little new stuff has proven expensive to introduce, with far too many niggles that have needed ironing out in the first quarter of its life. Older fleets have had to be refully refurbished twice and are all but life expired, with Project Churchward seemingly stalled. I mean, it's not difficult. Greater Anglia, with but a few hiccups, has shown the way in introducing a regional fleet suited to all routes. GWR has made some progress with battery electric, but that's a long way from fleet adoption, and I don't think repurposed LU rolling stock is the solution. Edge cases like the odd single line and self contained like the Isle of Wight, maybe. But not Trigger's broom across a large network with dozens of branches, regional and inter-urban services. Project Churchward. Now!
Compared to that it's easy to see Chiltern as a success of privatisation.
| Re: Different outlooks on nationalisation - GWR and Chiltern In "Chiltern Railways services" [381969/32728/44] Posted by Hafren at 22:39, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
Ironic with Chiltern Railways having been one of the big success stories of privatisation!
| Re: Different outlooks on nationalisation - GWR and Chiltern In "Chiltern Railways services" [381968/32728/44] Posted by Noggin at 21:54, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
Probably wise from GWR given the rolling stock issues.
Indeed. It feels like the perennial issue problem of the GWR franchise going back 20+ years has been stock availability, which has been almost entirely down to the DfT.
| Re: Different outlooks on nationalisation - GWR and Chiltern In "Chiltern Railways services" [381967/32728/44] Posted by grahame at 21:10, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
Probably wise from GWR given the rolling stock issues.
I cannot remember all the changes planned but one headline is the restoration of a half hourly Bristol Temple Meads to London Paddington for part of Sundays.
I cannot remember all the changes planned but one headline is the restoration of a half hourly Bristol Temple Meads to London Paddington for part of Sundays.
I missed ... most ... of the briefing the other week. Our schedule in Spain had gone dramatically wrong / missed connection into the second and last train to our booked hotel. Good to hear that.
| Re: Different outlooks on nationalisation - GWR and Chiltern In "Chiltern Railways services" [381966/32728/44] Posted by bobm at 20:47, 15th November 2026 Already liked by Mark A | ![]() |
Probably wise from GWR given the rolling stock issues.
I cannot remember all the changes planned but one headline is the restoration of a half hourly Bristol Temple Meads to London Paddington for part of Sundays.
| Re: GWR reassures passengers: No radical change after nationalisation on 13 Dec 2026 In "Across the West" [381965/32716/26] Posted by ray951 at 19:23, 15th November 2026 Already liked by Mark A | ![]() |
Speaking of budgets, in the Department for Transport annual report and accounts 2025 to 2026, figure 1.1 surprised me, it's a doozy.
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/dft-annual-report-and-accounts-2025-to-2026/department-for-transport-annual-report-and-accounts-2025-to-2026-html-version#financial-overview-from-the-director-general-for-the-corporate-delivery-group
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/dft-annual-report-and-accounts-2025-to-2026/department-for-transport-annual-report-and-accounts-2025-to-2026-html-version#financial-overview-from-the-director-general-for-the-corporate-delivery-group
Unless that chart omits a substantial source of road funding, those numbers seem hard to justify considering how much more passenger and freight traffic uses the road network than the rail network. If the chart is accurate, I'd be shocked if rail doesn't face a significant budget cut.
| Re: GWR reassures passengers: No radical change after nationalisation on 13 Dec 2026 In "Across the West" [381964/32716/26] Posted by Mark A at 18:20, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
Speaking of budgets, in the Department for Transport annual report and accounts 2025 to 2026, figure 1.1 surprised me, it's a doozy.
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/dft-annual-report-and-accounts-2025-to-2026/department-for-transport-annual-report-and-accounts-2025-to-2026-html-version#financial-overview-from-the-director-general-for-the-corporate-delivery-group
| Different outlooks on nationalisation - GWR and Chiltern In "Chiltern Railways services" [381963/32728/44] Posted by grahame at 18:11, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
From https://www.passenger.chat/r32716.html
GWR reassures passengers: No radical change after nationalisation on 13 Dec
From Chilrtem Railways
Your new timetable starts Sunday 13 December 2026
More services, more seats and more choice for your journey. From Sunday 13 December, we’re introducing 25 extra services every weekday and around 10,000 extra seats, giving you more options when you travel with us.
We update our timetable twice a year, but this December brings more changes than usual. Many train times will change, so please check your journey before you travel, even if you travel with us regularly.
Birmingham route: You’ll benefit from two trains an hour during the working week and more trains at weekends. More of our new Chiltern Explorer trains will be in service providing you with more First Class options and, for the first time, the opportunity to reserve selected seats when booking your train tickets.
Oxford route: You’ll have more services to choose from, alongside improved Class 168 trains - many of which already feature the refreshed external and interiors updates including onboard Wi-fi and access to plug sockets at every seat, the upgrade programme will continue into 2027, bringing these improvements to more of our trains.
Aylesbury (via Amersham) route: You’ll have two trains per hour during the working week, helping to make your commute to work more comfortable.
This is our first timetable change as a publicly owned railway. We’re focused on putting you first and working towards safe, reliable services you can trust.
What’s changing at your station? Search for your local station above to find out what the December timetable changes mean for you.
More services, more seats and more choice for your journey. From Sunday 13 December, we’re introducing 25 extra services every weekday and around 10,000 extra seats, giving you more options when you travel with us.
We update our timetable twice a year, but this December brings more changes than usual. Many train times will change, so please check your journey before you travel, even if you travel with us regularly.
Birmingham route: You’ll benefit from two trains an hour during the working week and more trains at weekends. More of our new Chiltern Explorer trains will be in service providing you with more First Class options and, for the first time, the opportunity to reserve selected seats when booking your train tickets.
Oxford route: You’ll have more services to choose from, alongside improved Class 168 trains - many of which already feature the refreshed external and interiors updates including onboard Wi-fi and access to plug sockets at every seat, the upgrade programme will continue into 2027, bringing these improvements to more of our trains.
Aylesbury (via Amersham) route: You’ll have two trains per hour during the working week, helping to make your commute to work more comfortable.
This is our first timetable change as a publicly owned railway. We’re focused on putting you first and working towards safe, reliable services you can trust.
What’s changing at your station? Search for your local station above to find out what the December timetable changes mean for you.
| Re: Marketing the express coach - lies, damned lies and statistics In "Smoke and Mirrors" [381961/32727/3] Posted by Mark A at 13:07, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
With promotions, is knocking the competition the best approach? Probably not.
However, I'm fine with GWR's one time strapline to the effect 'We intend to empty the M4' ...
| Re: GWR reassures passengers: No radical change after nationalisation on 13 Dec 2026 In "Across the West" [381960/32716/26] Posted by johnneyw at 13:05, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
........a lackadaisical approach to keeping the rail network in good condition.
In support of this statement I cite the enormous amount of 'scrap' rail, and other items such as old sleepers, left lying along the lineside
In support of this statement I cite the enormous amount of 'scrap' rail, and other items such as old sleepers, left lying along the lineside
Which reminds me of a much heralded, at the time, innovation to help tackle such issues in the form of a high tech detector train that was supposed it be able to identify and record the location such objects, at speed, even if obscured by vegetation. Not heard or seen much more about it since, or indeed any evidence of clearer line sides.
| Re: Class 175s to Great Western Railway (GWR) In "Across the West" [381959/28982/26] Posted by REVUpminster at 12:58, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
Some units are more reliable and have done a lot more passenger diagrams. Oddly the reliability extends to trains that came straight to Lara, and the one that went to Exeter, as well as those that went through Wolverton.
116 is due out tomorrow. Currently listed as out of service.
| Marketing the express coach - lies, damned lies and statistics In "Smoke and Mirrors" [381958/32727/3] Posted by grahame at 12:35, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
National Express Advert
Paying £65 for a train to sit on the floor by a stinky toilet? Absolutely not. Grab a guaranteed seat with direct travel to London from £6.50.
One-way fare. Save £1.50 with MyAccount. T&Cs apply.
One-way fare. Save £1.50 with MyAccount. T&Cs apply.
Hmmm ...
Not sure where that's from, but you are quoting £35 for a return journey on 21st December from my home town of Melksham, versus £47 I would pay on the train, where it would be highly unusual to have to sit on the floor near the toilet. The bus round trip is 8 hours, the train round trip is 3 - so of course value per travelling hour you are better value - just over £4 per hour rather than almost £16 per hour.
Personal preference is train. 5 hours less travel, the freedom to move around and to choose from multiple return times. Leaving home at 06:30 and back at 22:45 is a very long day. Buses and coaches DO have their place, but as a day trip to the centre of London this is not the mode I would choose.
Good to see. I'm a little puzzled by the "parachute-style" term though unless it just means it's circular (the best shape structurally so no great surprise) rather than square or oblong? Presumably Network Rail have made other arrangements at its originally-intended new location.
Not a term I have come across either, but a thumping great circular thing on the top of a few spindly columns, with the real reason for it being there in the first place - the water supply point - being at the base and "supported" by the thing above.
Cat litter?
Alternatively identify as a cat and then make use of your neighbour's front garden.

Good to see. I'm a little puzzled by the "parachute-style" term though unless it just means it's circular (the best shape structurally so no great surprise) rather than square or oblong? Presumably Network Rail have made other arrangements at its originally-intended new location.
| Re: GWR reassures passengers: No radical change after nationalisation on 13 Dec 2026 In "Across the West" [381954/32716/26] Posted by Bob_Blakey at 10:02, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
Even when the 'integrated' railway arrives in GWR land I would contend that the infrastructure outfit formerly known as Network Rail will, unless somebody in overall control forces them to improve, carry on with what looks remarkably like a lackadaisical approach to keeping the rail network in good condition.
In support of this statement I cite the enormous amount of 'scrap' rail, and other items such as old sleepers, left lying along the lineside, and the potentially destructive vegetation growing out of numerous bridges & viaducts. There are also plenty of instances where sidings are obviously OOU, and some cases where the track has been lifted or is completely overgrown, but signalling is still present and sometimes still powered up (e.g. the old cement terminal siding at the north end of EXC).
It all shows a lack of care and pride.
| Re: Delays on Devon services - merged posts, ongoing discussion In "Shorter journeys in Devon - Central, North and South" [381953/28378/24] Posted by GBM at 09:34, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
Cancellations to services at Exeter St Davids
Following urgent repairs to the track earlier today at Exeter St Davids all lines will be reopened shortly.
Train services running through this station may be cancelled or delayed. Disruption is expected until 10:00 15/11.
1A77 0830 Exeter St Davids to London Paddington left Exeter at 0931.
1A78 0827 Plymouth to London Paddington running 12 late approaching Starcross.
| Re: Class 175s to Great Western Railway (GWR) In "Across the West" [381952/28982/26] Posted by TaplowGreen at 09:20, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
Anyone have an idea of how many are in service now?
I know at least two are as both rolled in to Penzance last night within 10 minutes of each other
I know at least two are as both rolled in to Penzance last night within 10 minutes of each other
The train database lists 14 trains in service out of 18 at GWR. Just three diagrams of late; might be four tomorrow.
Statement of the obvious - that's pretty poor utilisation - 3 or 4 out of 26 trains, at a time when (please correct me if I am wrong) we might have expected somewhere around three quarters of them to be in service for passenger carrying every day.
Perhaps the definition of "in service" in this context would be useful - do they have to be serviceable to be considered "in service", or simply located at a GWR location, regardless of whether they are in working order?
| Re: Brighton Main Line - nine day closure warning, for 13 to 21 February 2027 In "The Wider Picture in the United Kingdom" [381951/32724/51] Posted by Mark A at 09:10, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
A recent comment prompted by the current pair of impactful IT failures to the effect that a company may lose experienced staff and then with a resilient system working well, the decision's taken to metaphorically 'Strips out the redundant wiring' - and the system continues to work well, which provides false reassurance to the decision makers. The system itself, however, is now fragile / in a spiral of decline / running on borrowed time, and sooner or later that is exposed either in a catastrophic way or by a general decline as the loss of capability is exposed. The phrase 'Minimum viable product'... the emphasis can land on 'Minimum' when it should be on 'Viable' - and 'Viable' for many provisions, must include the ability to adapt, to shrink to nothing, but also to grow, because without those qualities, the product is a zombie.
| Re: Brighton Main Line - nine day closure warning, for 13 to 21 February 2027 In "The Wider Picture in the United Kingdom" [381950/32724/51] Posted by Mark A at 08:57, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
Is it a fluke of history that Kent and Sussex has so many settlements that have retained alternative routes? For that part of the coast, for the future, there's the option of Brighton Main Line 2 - which hasn't (yet) been taken up - and for the duration of this work, is it that hourly(?) through trains are going to be provided via Horsham?
| Re: Class 175s to Great Western Railway (GWR) In "Across the West" [381949/28982/26] Posted by grahame at 08:33, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
Anyone have an idea of how many are in service now?
I know at least two are as both rolled in to Penzance last night within 10 minutes of each other
I know at least two are as both rolled in to Penzance last night within 10 minutes of each other
The train database lists 14 trains in service out of 18 at GWR. Just three diagrams of late; might be four tomorrow.
Statement of the obvious - that's pretty poor utilisation - 3 or 4 out of 26 trains, at a time when (please correct me if I am wrong) we might have expected somewhere around three quarters of them to be in service for passenger carrying every day.
| Re: Brighton Main Line - nine day closure warning, for 13 to 21 February 2027 In "The Wider Picture in the United Kingdom" [381948/32724/51] Posted by grahame at 08:29, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
Not the first time - what DO you do for major works on a mainline which has limited alternatives? At least in this case, through passengers can travel via Horsham - I question "and Littlehampton" which is a terminus at the end of a branch - not sure how much time it would add to the London to Brighton through trains to go in and out of there? Having said which, Brighton only has 2 and a bit platforms accessible from the west, so perhaps the diverted trains will also take up the paths of other trains on that line and also provide the Littlehampton service?
The south - old Southern Region and indeed old "Network South East" is well set with alternative routes. Until 1899, there was the "London Chatham and Dover" and the "South Eastern Railway" serving Maidstone, Canterbury and Dover and many other places through different lines. Bexhill and Hastings had services from the SECR and LBSCR. The London and South Western Railway and the London, Brighton and South Coast both had routes to take to to Portsmouth and through running tool you to Southampton too. And with the LSWR and GWR could take you to Weymouth. All of those lines still exist, though not necessarily with regular through services.
Away from the South (East), there are still two lines / routes available to Exeter, but beyond there a strategic gap now exists onwards to Plymouth which relies on the single route along the seawall at Dawish and over the hills at Dainton, Rattery and Hemerdon, all of which have been a challenge, and really it was a strategic blunder, though perhaps a finacially sensible decision, to close and rip up the alternative in 1968.
| Re: Class 175s to Great Western Railway (GWR) In "Across the West" [381947/28982/26] Posted by REVUpminster at 08:14, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
Anyone have an idea of how many are in service now?
I know at least two are as both rolled in to Penzance last night within 10 minutes of each other
I know at least two are as both rolled in to Penzance last night within 10 minutes of each other
The train database lists 14 trains in service out of 18 at GWR. Just three diagrams of late; might be four tomorrow.
| Re: TSSA members vote for strike action at GWR In "Across the West" [381946/32722/26] Posted by REVUpminster at 07:43, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
I was in the TSSA for 34 years from 1967 on the underground. We didn't strike had three sponsored MPs. The booking office salaries always reflected the post office and banks salaries. I went into the pension superannuation scheme at 17 whereas station staff, guards, drivers not until they were 24 expecting to do 40 years service by retirement age.
In those days they were not militant.
| Re: GWR reassures passengers: No radical change after nationalisation on 13 Dec 2026 In "Across the West" [381945/32716/26] Posted by REVUpminster at 07:33, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
No; if you count eighteen 175s operating three diagrams, reduced services, no increase in capacity anywhere on GWR, and Paignton station main entrance not opened four months after fire "ravaged" the footbridge. The staff and signaller still use the building.
| Re: To 'stockpile food' is now our Government's official policy, apparently In "The West - but NOT trains in the West" [381944/32456/31] Posted by broadgage at 07:11, 15th November 2026 | ![]() |
Some of us may know of the old Home Office buffer stores where emergency rations were stored. There was one outside Watlington close to the station, another on the Didcot, Newbury & Southampton line at Hermitage (or was that a cold store) and another between Steventon and Grove, served by a siding off the GWR. The first two were retained for some years after rail services ceased, and on the site of the one at Wallingford is a very new housing estate.
When there was a firemen's strike decades ago, army fire engines known as Green Goddesses stored at Steventon were deployed. As I was cycling on the main road between Tilehurst and Pangbourne, a column of them came the other way.
When there was a firemen's strike decades ago, army fire engines known as Green Goddesses stored at Steventon were deployed. As I was cycling on the main road between Tilehurst and Pangbourne, a column of them came the other way.
And how much food does HMG have stored for use by the civilian population these days ? None I suspect.
Mark Hopwood's GWR team have done a good job there, then.















