This is a test of GDPR / Cookie Acceptance [about our cookies]
Really irritating test - cookie expires in 24 hour!
Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
As at 9th November 2024 17:09 GMT
 
Re: Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
Posted by Electric train at 19:57, 21st October 2024
 
indeed - that was however the reason I was given about those services going to TfL when the DfT refused the Mayor's previous request.

But that was a Labour Mayor for London asking a Conservative Government who had pressure applied on it by Conservative lead local authorities in Kent and Sussex, the political power has changed the Conservative lead local authorities in Kent and Sussex now may protest to the DfT but if a Labour Mayor for London and a Labour Government want to put the Metro services into the hands of TfL it will happen.

Re: Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
Posted by ChrisB at 17:00, 21st October 2024
 
These sub-national Transport Authorities are going to be the consultees to the DfTs consultations, and it is looking likely that they'll be getting a budget fairly soon in order to carry out works for the DfT. They already cover the country, from Penninsular in the South West to Transport for Manchester in the north west.

Re: Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
Posted by eightonedee at 16:55, 21st October 2024
 
The previous three posts here illustrate the problems of devolution in our crowded country, where spheres of influence and economic zones overlap considerably.

I confess to having not heard of Transport for the South East. Having Googled them, I see that it is a forum for 16 local authorities. Quoting from their website-

Our small secretariat works closely with, and draws additional support from, senior officers from our constituent authorities, LEPs and other partners.

so it's far from the not-so-mini Department of Transport that TfL is, and therefore unlikely to have resources to be anything more than on a list of consultees. I am not sure that creating any other body in addition to GBR will bring much benefit, but that a proliferation of mayoral/regional passenger transport bodies might just be an even worse muddle than having different train operating companies on the same network.

Better that GBR has a regional structure (at least for passenger transport) and a statutory duty to consult with existing local transport and highway authorities?




Re: Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
Posted by ChrisB at 12:48, 21st October 2024
 
indeed - that was however the reason I was given about those services going to TfL when the DfT refused the Mayor's previous request.

Re: Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
Posted by ray951 at 12:40, 21st October 2024
 
The problem they would have with that suggestion for TfL/Mayor of London is that TfL isn't then accountable to the voters of the areas that these trains operate in, and thus they have no say in their level of services. This happens currently at the far end of the Met Line & Central Line, but in a small area. Widening this to a larger area will prove difficult without representation.

In my view, it is far likely for those services to be hived off to the sub-national transport bodies - in this case TftSE (Transport for the South-East)

ChrisB, I think you have forgotten ( ) that the Elizabeth Line to Reading is an example of this where the users don't have any representation for this service but where the money from fares goes to Tfl.

Re: Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
Posted by ChrisB at 12:25, 21st October 2024
 
The problem they would have with that suggestion for TfL/Mayor of London is that TfL isn't then accountable to the voters of the areas that these trains operate in, and thus they have no say in their level of services. This happens currently at the far end of the Met Line & Central Line, but in a small area. Widening this to a larger area will prove difficult without representation.

In my view, it is far likely for those services to be hived off to the sub-national transport bodies - in this case TftSE (Transport for the South-East)

Re: Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
Posted by Electric train at 07:24, 21st October 2024
 
What they can do - and I suspect will do, if they remain in power - is to start buying their own trains as the current ones need replacing - rather than contracting anew with the ROSCOs for them. That way the ROSCOs simply end up with worthless age-expired stock & probably go out of business. Without costing the Government very much.

Will that require any new legislation?  Are there any conditions within the current legislation that "protects" the ROSCOs from this happening or from any additional competition entering the market?

An example are class 710 EMU's that operate London Overground services, these units are owned by TfL, RoSCo's are not involved in the ownership of the class 345 on the Elizabeth Line.

So in short, its not a legal requirement to use a ROSCo.

I can foresee that once all (or at least the majority) of the TOC's are under the control of GBR, the Government will set about recasting the shape of the TOCs.  I feel the Government will hand metro services over to the metro Mayors, eg TfL taking over the SE Trains, Southern, SWR inner London services and what is left formed into a new Southern, the same will happen in other areas of the country.

This will, in my opinion, fit into the current Government devolution to metro Mayors and regions

Re: Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
Posted by ray951 at 20:24, 19th October 2024
 
What they can do - and I suspect will do, if they remain in power - is to start buying their own trains as the current ones need replacing - rather than contracting anew with the ROSCOs for them. That way the ROSCOs simply end up with worthless age-expired stock & probably go out of business. Without costing the Government very much.

I agree in that I think they should do this, but they won't, as letting the ROSCO's buy the trains keeps the cost of purchase off the government balance sheet even though in the long term it would be cheaper for the government/taxpayer/railway.
I would gladly be happy to be provided wrong on this.


Re: Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
Posted by johnneyw at 15:59, 19th October 2024
 
Perhaps another consideration is to ensure that, should the government make it clear that they will be buying their own rolling stock in future, the TOC's don't resort to a "fire sale" of their stock (abroad?) while they still have some value.....resulting in more severe rolling stock shortages here.

Re: Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
Posted by ChrisB at 13:25, 19th October 2024
 
Not that I am aware of for new stock orders.

Re: Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
Posted by johnneyw at 12:58, 19th October 2024
 
What they can do - and I suspect will do, if they remain in power - is to start buying their own trains as the current ones need replacing - rather than contracting anew with the ROSCOs for them. That way the ROSCOs simply end up with worthless age-expired stock & probably go out of business. Without costing the Government very much.

Will that require any new legislation?  Are there any conditions within the current legislation that "protects" the ROSCOs from this happening or from any additional competition entering the market?

Re: Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
Posted by ChrisB at 10:59, 19th October 2024
 
What they can do - and I suspect will do, if they remain in power - is to start buying their own trains as the current ones need replacing - rather than contracting anew with the ROSCOs for them. That way the ROSCOs simply end up with worthless age-expired stock & probably go out of business. Without costing the Government very much.

Re: Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
Posted by grahame at 06:07, 19th October 2024
 
Although the new Government states it will take back all the TOC's,I still think the biggest issue is the Roscos.

As Tfw controls a smaller area and has some sort of control over its train sets.

Could Tfw buy its own sets, as opposed to new and older sets having to be leased from the Roscos?

The RoSCos are a far bigger "issue".

As I understand it, it would be very expensive - money the governments don't have - to buy [back] the trains owned by the RoSCos.  Furthermore, The Government wants to encourage private investment and public / private partnerships and to buy out or renationalise the RoSCos would be a warning to anyone looking to invest that they might end up taking all the risk.   

Rather different with the TOCs who have a lot less physical resource (hardly any - the "O" stands for operating not owning) and in any case most of th operating contracts have over time proven to generate slim income for a lot of hard work.

I'm not sure what the contracts between the RoSCos and the TOCs are - but I don't think that HMG could simply return the private trains and buy more of their own.  The Hitachi units (class 800) have a long term contract, the 802s a somewhat different setup, I believe.   As GWR - perhaps  takes on class 175s there's th question for everyone concerned as to their future as, when, if, and however the First group are no longer operating trains in the Western Peninsular.


Could Wales and maybe Scotland buy its own trains?
Posted by infoman at 05:43, 19th October 2024
 
Although the new Government states it will take back all the TOC's,I still think the biggest issue is the Roscos.

As Tfw controls a smaller area and has some sort of control over its train sets.

Could Tfw buy its own sets, as opposed to new and older sets having to be leased from the Roscos?

 
The Coffee Shop forum is provided by customers of Great Western Railway (formerly First Great Western). The views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit https://www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that the content provided by one of our posters contravenes our posting rules ( graham AT sn12.net ).

Although we are planning ahead, we don't know what the future will bring here in the Coffee Shop. We have domains "firstgreatwestern.info" for w-a-y back and also "greatwesternrailway.info"; we can also answer to "greatbritishrailways.info" too. For the future, information about Great Brisish Railways, by customers and for customers.
 
Current Running
GWR trains from JourneyCheck
 
Links in development

Member contributions
Recent new POSTS
Recent new THREADS
Popular Threads
Member Polls
Transport Diary
So far this month
Search for

Also on our site
About the forum
Whitelisted (public) documents
On this travel day
2B added - Individual Station Data

User site admin
Tailor your experience

Externnal Links
JourneyCheck
2B added - Live Station updates
2B added - Booking engine links
BBC news feed

Old site pages - active
About the Coffee Shop
Acronymns and Abbreviations

Old site pages - being replaced
BBC News Feed
Recent New Topics
Popular Threads
Members Polls
On this day
Diary
So far this month
Forum Home Page
 
Code Updated 13th September 2024
From https://greatwesternrailway.info/t29328.html - go insecure