This is a test of GDPR / Cookie Acceptance [about our cookies]
Really irritating test - cookie expires in 24 hour!
How do we look ahead - Transport Analysis Guidance
As at 6th November 2024 20:20 GMT
 
How do we look ahead - Transport Analysis Guidance
Posted by grahame at 08:24, 29th October 2024
 
First published 29th October 2013 and to be found via https://www.gov.uk/guidance/transport-analysis-guidance-tag

Transport analysis guidance (TAG) provides information on the role of transport modelling and appraisal.

From:Department for Transport
Published 29 October 2013
Last updated17 October 2024


The link given is the tip of an iceberg.   There is massive sense in analysing transport flows - current ones and potential future ones - to help ensure we move forward with best systems for the future - but my goodness it gets complicated.  As far as I can see, there is no single download link for TAG guidance, and no layman's introduction or tutorial - but then is this something that is of any use or interest to people using the service and supportive of it being tuned?

Can any of our more technical member's summarise TAG?

Re: How do we look ahead - Transport Analysis Guidance
Posted by CyclingSid at 11:23, 29th October 2024
 
As you suggest TAG, or WebTAG, is massive. Have tried using some of the stuff relating to active travel, hard work or beyond my abilities. I used the value of a life in various health related analyses. I presume it is also used for railway assessment. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/webtag-tag-unit-a5-3-rail-appraisal-may-2018. The TAG data book https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/tag-data-book is possibly useful to get an idea of the content.
It, or its component parts, are updated on a fairly regular basis.
Clarified guidance on application of optimism bias for rail projects

TAG unit A5.3 (rail appraisal) provides recommended uplifts for optimism bias, for both capital and operational expenditure. An updated version of unit A5.3, to be published in November 2024, will include clarification on the application of optimism bias to gross or net operational expenditure. The updated guidance will advise that the analyst should consider the importance of network-wide cost savings to the intervention in question in choosing whether to apply optimism bias to gross or net operating costs.

Re: How do we look ahead - Transport Analysis Guidance
Posted by Trowres at 21:17, 29th October 2024
 
This link seems to give a reasonably useful overview: reasonable depth without getting into the horrific fine detail of methodology:

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/tag-guidance-for-the-senior-responsible-officer-may-2018

A few observations:
1. Following the guidance should give some credibility to the idea that forecasts for different projects are comparable; it doesn't necessarily lead to  forecasts that are accurate.

2. There is some mention in the guidance of proportionality. That is: small projects should not need the same level of analysis as large, expensive projects. I'm not sure that this principle is followed throughout the guidance.

3. The three-stage appraisal process: SOBC,OBC, and finally full business case tends to lead to a lot of re-work. Although, in theory, each stage is adding more detail, producing more accurate forecasts, it can feel like paying for the same work over and over again.

4. Forecasting demand is based on evidence, but evidence is more abundant for some types of project than for others. For example, most new stations post-Beeching have been suburban stations aimed at commuters (and others travelling into cities), so an evidence base has grown from the outcome of such stations. Evidence for completely new train services and for (say) stations serving leisure destinations is harder to find.

5. The complete appraisal process is laboriously technical, which is why there are consultants who are happy to earn a living from the work. Even so, they sometimes make mistakes, such as double-counting or omitting significant elements of cost.

6. There are basic forecasting techniques that are within the grasp of the keen amateur, needing nothing more than a spreadsheet and data - much of which is published.

7. We all love to suggest new stations and services. It would be a step forward to subject these to a bit of homebrew appraisal (because it's surprising how far/long some ideas float around without any idea existing of whether or not they could be viable).



Re: How do we look ahead - Transport Analysis Guidance
Posted by Mark A at 09:25, 30th October 2024
 
A thread from Bluesky that throws light on another aspect to this perhaps.

Mark


https://bsky.app/profile/joesarling.bsky.social/post/3l7bgo3debh2m

 
The Coffee Shop forum is provided by customers of Great Western Railway (formerly First Great Western). The views expressed are those of the individual posters concerned. Visit https://www.gwr.com for the official Great Western Railway website. Please contact the administrators of this site if you feel that the content provided by one of our posters contravenes our posting rules ( graham AT sn12.net ).

Although we are planning ahead, we don't know what the future will bring here in the Coffee Shop. We have domains "firstgreatwestern.info" for w-a-y back and also "greatwesternrailway.info"; we can also answer to "greatbritishrailways.info" too. For the future, information about Great Brisish Railways, by customers and for customers.
 
Current Running
GWR trains from JourneyCheck
 
Links in development

Member contributions
Recent new POSTS
Recent new THREADS
Popular Threads
Member Polls
Transport Diary
So far this month
Search for

Also on our site
About the forum
Whitelisted (public) documents
On this travel day
2B added - Individual Station Data

User site admin
Tailor your experience

Externnal Links
JourneyCheck
2B added - Live Station updates
2B added - Booking engine links
BBC news feed

Old site pages - active
About the Coffee Shop
Acronymns and Abbreviations

Old site pages - being replaced
BBC News Feed
Recent New Topics
Popular Threads
Members Polls
On this day
Diary
So far this month
Forum Home Page
 
Code Updated 13th September 2024
From https://greatwesternrailway.info/r29380.html - go insecure